Public Defender’s Statement on Nika Gvaramia Case

Published in Society
Tuesday, 17 May 2022 11:11

On May 11, 2022, the final hearing was held in connection with the case of Nika Gvaramia, former Director General of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting TV Company Ltd. We would like to remind the public that on November 4, 2019, the Public Defender filed an amicus curiae brief with Tbilisi City Court relating to one of the episodes of the mentioned case. The document is based on key issues identified as a result of studying the case materials and reviews correlation between corporate-legal and criminal liabilities.

In the amicus curiae brief, the Public Defender indicates that the decision made by the manager of the enterprise (changing the terms of the contract, determining the amount of income), which was agreed with the owner of the enterprise, is considered a crime in the given case. According to the indictment, the director could have brought more income to the company but he did not do so, which is a crime.

The amicus curiae brief reviews the practices of the courts of the USA, UK, continental European countries and Georgia, according to which, such an entrepreneurial decision may not lead even to corporate liability, not to mention criminal liability. The decision made by the director might be to make less profit, but it might serve the best interests of the corporation and aim to insure against short-term or long-term risks.

In this case, corporate-legal liability should be ruled out, as the decision made by the director was not: (1) an action that was not agreed with partners (use of dominant position), (2) aimed at personal enrichment through fraud, and (3) risk analysis reasonably indicates that the move was in the best interests of the corporation. Moreover, criminal liability should also be ruled out, as the director has not committed a criminal action in order to make a profit. Clearly, changing the terms of the contract for the basic needs of the corporation does not constitute a crime.

Thus, the managerial decision made during the management of the enterprise cannot be evaluated without taking into account the specifics of the legal status of the director. The Public Defender hopes that this document will help the court fairly assess the case circumstances and make the right decision, taking into account the international experience and practice regarding the elements of director's responsibilities.

Read 67 times

Related items

  • Statement of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Georgia regarding the NATO Summit in Madrid

    The Madrid Summit decisions, including both their practical and political dimensions, are of paramount importance to Georgia. 
    In view of the challenges facing us, the further development of NATO-Georgia practical cooperation and the deepening of the political dialogue are  essential for the improvement of regional security. We hail the approval by the Allies of a set of tailored support measures for Georgia. The document envisages concrete steps to further enhance Georgia’s defence capabilities and to achieve NATO’s more effective engagement in this process. This new instrument, along with the Substantial NATO-Georgia Package, will create a greater scope for bringing Georgia’s defence and security sector closer to NATO standards and to strengthen the country’s defence capabilities.  
    Georgia welcomes the adoption of a new strategic concept by the NATO Summit in Madrid. The new concept duly reflects the recent geopolitical shifts and the Alliance’s long-term response to the emerging threats. It needs to be highlighted that the new strategic concept gives due consideration to the topical importance of the Open Door Policy and to Georgia’s membership perspective, in line with the 2008 Bucharest Summit Decision, as well as  to the fundamental principle that each sovereign country has the right to choose its own security arrangements, without external interference in any form.
    Paramount importance needs to be attached to NATO’s unequivocal support for Georgia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, as confirmed repeatedly in several  documents adopted by the Madrid Summit. 
    Georgia highly appraises the Madrid Summit decisions to further strengthen the security of the NATO Member States, as well as to ensure the Black Sea security.  
    We also welcome the Madrid Summit’s decision regarding the enlargement of the Alliance. We congratulate Finland and Sweden on being invited to join the Alliance. Their accession will make Europe safer and the Alliance – stronger. Being the actual implementation of the Open Door Policy, this process is essentially important for Georgia, as an aspirant country.  We also hail the decision of the Alliance to continue to support Ukraine. 
    Georgia places a particularly high value on the messages voiced during the North Atlantic Council’s meeting signaling the Member States’ firm support for Georgia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, as well as for its Euro-Atlantic integration. 
    The decisions made regarding Georgia during the Summit will contribute to improving Georgia’s security and defence capabilities and will bring the country closer to its ultimate goal – NATO Membership.

    MFA of Georgia

  • Public Defender’s Letter to European Council President Charles Michel

    On June 22, 2022, the Public Defender of Georgia sent an official letter to the President of the European Council, Charles Michel, requesting the President and the Heads of the EU Member States to consider the aspirations of the Georgian people towards the European family, their fight and efforts in this process, and to grant Georgia a candidate status, in order to prevent that Georgia is separated from the common space it has shared with Ukraine and Moldova and misses this important opportunity.

    See the letter of the Public Defender of Georgia to Charles MichelPresident of the European Council

    Your Excellency, I hereby extend the assurances of my highest consideration personally to you, as well as the President of the European Commission, and the Heads of State/Government of the 27 EU Member States. The EU has always been a firm supporter of Georgia in its European aspirations and the results of this support have been felt by many of us for decades. Let me express our utmost gratitude for this assistance. I remain convinced that the EU-Georgian cooperation will keep strengthening, while the progress that comes with the European integration will benefit the citizens of both the EU and Georgia who share the common values and are united in forging more humane, peaceful, and prosperous future.

    I am addressing you today as the Public Defender (Ombudsman) of Georgia, which is an independent constitutional body that supervises the protection of human rights and freedoms by public authorities in Georgia. The Ombudsman has over the decades been acting resolutely within its constitutional mandate and enjoys a wide support and trust from the members of the public as well as the international community at large.

    During such critical times I feel obliged to address you ahead of the upcoming European Council meeting on 23 and 24 June 2022, which is expected to make a final decision about the membership applications from Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova and Georgia. As you are aware, on 17th of June 2022, the European Commission issued Opinions on Georgia’s, the Republic of Moldova’s and Ukraine’s application for the EU membership in which the Commission recommended granting European Perspective to all three states. Furthermore, while for Ukraine and the Republic of Moldova the Commission recommended granting a candidate status, with respect to Georgia the Commission has put forward a clear set of conditions to be met before the candidate status is granted. This risks separation of Georgia from the rest of the Associated Trio, even though it has been seen for many years as a frontrunner among the three and shares with them the threats coming from the Russian Federation.

    This is an existential matter and moment for the whole nation, who have already made their conscious choice of European and Euro-Atlantic integration, embodied in the Constitution of Georgia. In Georgia the European integration is not only a foreign policy option, but a moral and cultural choice shared by a wider political spectrum and supported by the absolute majority of Georgians. Unprecedented number of demonstrators marching in Tbilisi on the 20th of June is a recent confirmation of this. The civil society led rally was held for the sole purpose of expressing unwavering support for Georgia’s EU integration, regardless of the political affiliation. Europe is a historic choice and aspiration of the Georgian people, for which all generations have made sacrifices. The idea of European perspective consolidates society and reduces polarization

    Consequently, in the face of the most acute domestic and foreign policy challenges, it is crucial for us now that Georgia, together with Ukraine and the Republic of Moldova, is granted the EU candidate status with the precise conditions to be met within strict timelines. The European Commission has already outlined the most challenging issues to be addressed immediately by Georgia and let me confirm that the issues set out in the Opinion have been voiced by the civil society and majority of Georgians, as well as the Ombudsman for many years already.

    It is for the reasons outlined above that I appeal to you today to consider granting the EU candidate status to Georgia. I firmly believe that the European integration is the only driving force for a progress in Georgia and the recommendations of the European Commission will act as a road map in this process. Let me assure you that the Public Defender will oversee this process and the Georgian people, civil society, and the media will be there to safeguard the fulfillment of these conditions.

    Please accept, You Excellency, the assurances of my highest consideration!

    Yours sincerely,

    Nino Lomjaria

    The Public Defender (Ombudsman) of Georgia

  • U.S. Embassy Statement on the Ruling in the Cases of Gvaramia, Iashvili, and Damenia

    Today’s ruling, in the cases of Gvaramia, Iashvili, and Damenia, calls into question Georgia’s commitment to rule of law, and further demonstrates the fundamental importance of having an independent, impartial judiciary in Georgia. From its inception, this case has raised questions, including about the timing and the charges. The disturbing pattern of selective investigations and prosecutions targeting those in opposition to the current government undermines the public’s confidence in the police, prosecution, the courts, and the government itself. Particularly at this time, when Georgia has an unprecedented opportunity to advance its Euro-Atlantic integration, even the perception of politicized prosecution is detrimental. It is the United States’ firm position that a healthy democracy depends on ensuring judicial independence and protecting media freedom. That is why we have repeatedly called for the government to undertake comprehensive reforms to advance these fundamental democratic principles.

    By 

     

  • STATEMENT OF THE PROSECUTION SERVICE

    According to the administration of the Prosecution Service of Georgia, Tbilisi City Court found Nika Gvaramia, former Director General of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD, guilty of causing the company a damage of GEL 6,763,509. 

    In this part, Tbilisi City Court upheld the evidence submitted by the Prosecution but did not agree with the latter’s assessment of the legal classification of the crime. As a result, the act committed by the defendant was classified as abuse of power in a commercial organization – Article 220 instead of Article 182 of the Criminal Code of Georgia. Nika Gvaramia was sentenced to a fine of GEL 50,000 in this episode. 
    Moreover, Nika Gvaramia was found guilty of abuse of power in a commercial organization under Article 220 of the Criminal Code of Georgia and he was subsequently sentenced to imprisonment for a term of three years and six months. The Court acquitted Nika Gvaramia of all the other charges brought.
    In the same manner, Kakhaber Damenia, former Financial Director of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD was found guilty of causing the company a damage of GEL 6,763,509. In this case as well, Tbilisi City Court fully upheld the evidence submitted by the Prosecution but did not agree with the latter’s assessment of the legal classification of the crime. As a result, the act committed by the defendant was classified as abuse of power in a commercial organization – Article 220 instead of Article 182 of the Criminal Code of Georgia. Kakhaber Damenia was sentenced to a fine of GEL 50,000.
    As regards to Zurab Iashvili, Tbilisi City Court fully acquitted him of the charges brought on him. 
    We would like to remind the public that Nika Gvaramia had been charged with embezzlement of the property right of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD in large amount, commercial bribery, making and using a forged official document, money laundering and abuse of power in a commercial organization. 
    Kakhaber Damenia had been charged with embezzlement of the property right of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD in large amount.
    Zurab Iashvili had been charged with commercial bribery and making and using a forged official document. 
    According to the charge brought, on January 16, 2015, Nika Gvaramia concluded an agreement with Inter Media Plus LTD on behalf of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD. Pursuant to the agreement, Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD conceded its right to display commercial advertisements on its channels to Inter Media Plus LTD. 
    From January through August 2015, Nika Gvaramia claimed 90-95% of the total income received as a result of selling advertising time of the company from Inter Media Plus LTD, whereas he left the remaining funds with the latter in return for the provision of service. 
    After Kibar Khalvashi started a court dispute on August 5, 2015 to return the shares of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD, Nika Gvaramia and Kakhaber Damenia, acting against Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD and clearly neglecting its interests, started claiming only the funds necessary for the existence of the TV company every month from Inter Media Plus LTD.
    The total revenue to be received by Inter Media Plus LTD in 2015 from selling the advertising time of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD added up to GEL 48,014,847, out of which the company only paid GEL 36,467 000 to Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD. This was less by GEL 6,763,509 compared to the funds received for the same service in 2014. As a consequence, in the second half of 2015, N. Gvaramia and K. Damenia embezzled the right to claim GEL 6,763,509 from Inter Media Plus LTD. 
    Nika Gvaramia, with the help of Zurab Iashvili, Director of Inter Media Plus LTD, received benefits in the form of real estate from the company in return for the embezzlement of an especially large amount of property right – worth GEL 6,763,509 – for the benefit of Inter Media Plus LTD, which belonged to Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD. In particular, Gvaramia received two apartments located on Mukhadze Street, Tbilisi with the total area of 238.74 square meters. 
    After Nika Gvaramia illegally received real estate from Inter Media Plus LTD, he intended to render the criminally-obtained property legal. As a result, several months after the real estate was registered under his name, he sold both apartments to different people in July and September 2017. In this way, he received income of especially large amount – GEL 602,521.8. 
    Apart from the above-mentioned, in February 2019, N. Gvaramia made an offer to the management of Tegeta Premium Vehicles (Porsche Center) against the lawful interest of Rustavi 2 Broadcasting Company LTD – he would buy an expensive vehicle from them in return for displaying commercial advertisements about their company on Rustavi 2, which he would do through the advertising agency associated with him – Proesco Media LTD. 
    As agreed, on February 27, 2019, a purchase agreement on Porsche Macan S worth EUR 76,700 was concluded between Tegeta Premium Vehicles LTD and Proesco Media LTD. Based on the agreement, the vehicle was transferred under the factual ownership of Nika Gvaramia and his family, while Proesco Media LTD became the formal owner of the car.
    Although Tegeta Premium Vehicles met the requirements of the agreement in good faith and fully paid the advertising price set by the agreement to Proesco Media LTD, under Nika Gvaaramia’s instruction, the latter significantly reduced the amounts to be paid to Rustavi 2, which caused the TV company considerable damage. 
    Between April and July 2019, the TV company suffered a financial loss of large amount, while Nika Gvaramia and his family gained factual ownership of Porsche Macan S, which cost GEL 232,201. 
    The Prosecution will appeal today’s court decision before the appellate court within the term established by the law. 

  • Judge sentenced Nika Gvaramia to 3 years and 6 months in prison

    The judge has sentenced Nika Gvaramia to 3 years and 6 months of imprisonment and ordered him to be held in custody in the courtroom.

    Judge of Tbilisi City Court Lasha Chkhikvadze announced the decision a few minutes ago.

    The prosecution accuses Niki Gvaramia of "abuse of power against the legitimate interests of the TV company and misuse of a large amount of its assets." Along with him are two more accused - Kakha Damenia and Zurab Iashvili.

    Source: https://mtavari.tv/en/news/85421-judge-sentenced-nika-gvaramia-3-years-and-6

Business News

Silk Road Tbilisi Forum 2015 has started

Silk Road Tbilisi Forum 2015 has started

Silk Road Tbilisi 2015 forum started today. Following the success of the inaugural Routes Silk Road...

Agreement between SES and GEE

Agreement between SES and GEE

A new multi-year agreement was signed between worldwide satellite operator SES and Global Eagle Ente...

Visa free regime to impose for 15 February

Visa free regime to impose for 15 February

The visa regime imposed by Georgia to Iran has been cancelled for 15 February,” -the Deputy Ambassad...

Session of Economic Council was held under the leadership of Prime Minister

Session of Economic Council was held under the leadership of Prime Minister

Plan of acceleration of infrastructural projects, financial support scheme for startups and activiti...

MOST READ

« July 2022 »
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

About

The News Agency,
NEWSDAY.GE is
a part of STARVISION
Media Group.
It made its first
appearance on the Internet..More

 

Contact

NEWSDAY Ltd.
Lechkhumi street.43

Georgia,Tbilisi

Phone: (+995 32) 257 91 11
E-mail: avtandil@yahoo.com

 

 

 

Social Media